Report of the working group on the interaction between social and cognitive processes at the AAAI 2000 Fall Symposium on Socially Intelligent Agents - the human in the loop, North Falmouth, MA, USA, November 2000.
Participants:
- Bruce Edmonds (Organiser)
- Yuri Ivanov
- Tony Jebura
- Jim Kennedy
- Per Persson
- Lynn Rampold
- Bill Tomlinson
A brief overview of the topics discussed:
- The appropriate level of modelling of social and cognitive processes, that over-simple models can be misleadingly effective in the very short term but over complex models are difficult to generalise from
- The need for a rich and complete data source documenting a few real social processes rather than many field studies of different processes, this would enable the detailed modelling of the same social process from different perspectives
- The learning vs. the design stance - whether we attempt to explicitly design in social intelligence or whether it needs to be learnt in situ - maybe we need to learn how to train social agents
- The inevitable unevenness of the learning curve by academics in this area - sometimes we have to unlearn things for progress
- That researchers should be satisfied with less impressive results and focus more on deeper progress - specifically quick hacks to achieve outwardly more impressive results (which are common in the field) should be avoided
- The tension between the desired generality for knowledge and tools and the context specific nature of much social knowledge and skills
Some test problems for socially intelligent agents
- Can an artificial salesman achieve real sales
- A restricted game of Diplomacy with a limited repertoire of allowed messages between players
- How long can an artificial agent keep a human interested in a text-only on-line conversation